What to Eat on Margaritaville at Sea – The Islander | Food Review & Tips
Let’s talk about the food on Margaritaville at Sea The Islander. If you’re looking for an easygoing cruise with casual meals, tropical drinks, and a few tasty surprises, this ship delivers. While it may not win awards for fine dining, there are definitely some flavorful highlights worth trying.
Here’s an honest look at what to eat on board, including must-try bites, spice-level tips, and dress code details.
Fins Dining Room – Rotating Menus and Classic Dishes
The Fins Dining Room is the main sit-down restaurant. It offers rotating menus each night. The one above is a sample. Popular dishes include jerk chicken, mahi mahi, and carved meats. The vibe is casual, but the service feels elegant.
Save room for dessert. The key lime pie is one of the best things I tasted all cruise.
Dress Code – What to Pack and Wear
Wondering what to wear while dining on board? The dress code on The Islander is resort casual. Most people wear sundresses, polos, or shorts. Flip-flops are fine in most areas.
For JWB Prime Steakhouse, aim for smart casual. Collared shirts and nice tops are perfect. No formal attire needed—leave the suits and gowns at home.
Spice Levels – Ask Before You Bite
A quick word of advice: some dishes come with bold, spicy flavors. If you have a sensitive palate like I do, check with your server before ordering. I ran into a few entrees that were too spicy for me. Luckily, the staff is happy to guide you to milder options.
JWB Prime Steakhouse – Premium Dining for a Special Night
For something extra, try JWB Prime Steakhouse. It’s a specialty restaurant, and it’s worth the upgrade. Steaks are juicy, seafood is fresh, and sides like truffle mac and creamed spinach are indulgent.
It’s the perfect place for a date night or birthday celebration.
Cheeseburger in Paradise Burger Bar – A Classic Bite by the Pool
This is a cruise highlight! The Cheeseburger in Paradise Burger Bar serves juicy burgers topped your way. Add cheese, bacon, and all the fixings. The fries are crispy, and the vibe is pure fun.
Yes—they play the “Cheeseburger in Paradise” song while you eat. It’s a great lunch stop between pool time and port days.
Port of Indecision Buffet – Variety for Everyone
The buffet offers something for everyone. Breakfast includes made-to-order omelets, pastries, and fruit. Lunch and dinner bring pizza, pasta, salads, tacos, and more.
If you’re hungry and want quick options, this is the place to go. Just be aware: the line can get long during peak hours.
Frank & Lola’s Pizzeria – Late-Night Fuel
After live music or a night at the bar, Frank & Lola’s Pizzeria hits the spot. The pizza is thin-crust and available by the slice. I liked the pepperoni and garlic white pie best.
This spot is open late, which is perfect for night owls.
Desserts and Ice Cream – Sweet Finishes
Dessert lovers, rejoice. From cakes and cookies to soft-serve by the pool, you’ll find plenty of sweets. Try something new each day. The pastry chefs mix things up with tropical-inspired flavors.
Drinks and Bars – Toast to Vacation
The Islander has multiple bars with beachy vibes. From margaritas to frozen daiquiris, there’s something for every taste. Try the 5 o’Clock Somewhere Bar for live music and people-watching.
Don’t forget: many drinks are included, but specialty cocktails are an extra charge. Personally, I love the bubble up bar.
Final Thoughts – Honest Review of the Food
The food on Margaritaville at Sea The Islander is fun, filling, and perfect for a laid-back vacation. While it’s not gourmet, it matches the cruise’s casual, upbeat vibe.
Come with an open mind, ask about spice levels, and enjoy what this ship does best—easy eats, strong drinks, and island vibes.
🍴 Ready to Cruise?
Want help booking your Margaritaville cruise? I’ve got exclusive tips, perks, and offers. Reach out today to book your trip at danna@takeatriptoday.com or call/text 352-209-2792.
You May Also Like
Getting Ready for Paradise: Packing & Prepping for My Margaritaville at Sea Cruise!
Day One – Departing Tampa Bay – Phins Up
